Did RSV mistranslate arsenokoitēs as 'homosexuals'? Examining the claims of the film '1946'
“As with his other New Testament letters, some argue that Paul was preaching against temple prostitution or pederasty in the passage.” - CPost
- 47 views
If “arsenokoitai” is supposed to mean just shrine prostitution or pederasty, we would expect similar phrasings regarding the far more numerous female shrine prostitutes and/or standard prostitutes. But that said, the word “porneia” is used, which although it does refer to prostitution, had come to mean any sex outside of marriage in the Hellenic Jewish context.
Since the parallel phrase is broad and refers to anything outside of marriage in a heterosexual context, we’d anticipate the same spread of meaning in a homosexual context. Moreover, Paul for whatever reason uses two words to describe male homosexuality—malakoi and arsenokoitai—corresponding roughly to the rather coarse terms used today, “bottom” and “top”.
“1946” is more or less hoping that their readers either do not know, or do not care, that Paul’s writing mirrors not cultic prostitution, but contemporary practice in homosexuality.
Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.
Do you think 1946 has an agenda?
Ya think?!!
https://www.1946themovie.com/creators
Teresa & Todd Silver became allies when their son, raised in their evangelical household, came out in 2014. Supporting ministries for decades they naturally became advocates for LGBTQ+ individuals and supportive organizations
Discussion