Skip to main content
SHARPER IRON
“As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.” (Proverbs 27:17)
  • About
    • About Sharper Iron
    • Doctrinal Statement
    • Contact
    • Search
  • Forum
    • Forum Home
    • Comment Guidelines
    • Search
  • Account
    • Log in
    • Register

Do Church Worship Bands Keep People From Singing?

By Filings on Tue, 10/27/26
Church & Ministry
Congregational Singing
Worship Music
Contemporary Worship

“In most churches today, the worship time has become a concert. People love the music, but they don’t know the words, and so they just watch. I visit churches pretty much for a living, and as I look around during the services, the vast numbers of the congregation are watching the stage and listening, not singing.” - Phil Cooke

Discussion

User image
dgszweda

NewThe problem I see are: For…

Tue, 10/27/26

The problem I see are:

  • For some churches the words are not displayed
  • For some of the music the style and song is great for an album but poor for a congregation to sing who may even not be familiar with the song
  • The music is sung by the worship team in a performative style in both music as well as words and not a congregational style
  • The instruments and singing are so loud that you can't hear yourself sing

Profile picture for user Bert Perry
Bert Perry

NewWell said

Tue, 10/27/26

I was dreading another issue on music, but Phil Cooke gets it right. Many times, if the congregation does not know the tune, or the tune is too high/too low, people won't sing. David's comments are also helpful--you can pick up on a new tune of the words are on the screen. Really, part of the beauty of the old hymnals is that if you can read--especially reading music--you can pick up the new tunes. And miracle of miracles, you can put modern songs in a hymnal, too.

Then you have the issue of "how do people read a hymnal when the lights are dimmed and the fog generators are working?".

Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.

Profile picture for user dcbii
dcbii

NewWhy people don't sing

Tue, 10/27/26

All of David’s points above are relevant. Bert added one that applies to me — being able to read the music. Since I can read decently, if not great, I do NOT enjoy trying to learn a song from just words on a screen. The church should either hand out music sheets in the bulletin (that’s what my church does), or use things actually already in the hymnal.

Many modern worship songs, even if they have a singable tune in a good key and great lyrics with good theology, have timing changes or note changes at different points in the song, etc. I’m perfectly willing to learn, but I have no interest in sticking out when I can’t just “divine” the next notes and timing. So with these songs, without music I’ll typically either stay silent for the whole song the first time it is used, or I might chime in on the 3rd/4th verse if the song is regular enough. Thankfully, my church is fairly traditional, so there is no lowered lighting, fog machines, loud worship teams, etc. And again, for almost all new songs, song sheets with notes are handed out.

For new music, anthems, or arrangements of familiar music, a worship team or traditional choir (what my church has, and I’m in it) can be used. For us, it’s only one number out of the 4 or 5 sung, with the rest being congregational. There are a couple people who make no secret of the fact they think no music should be done that isn’t sung by the congregation, but that point of view is not shared by most, who generally think choir pieces add, rather than detract, from the service.

Overall, I agree, that article was pretty good. We should be doing all we can to get the congregation to participate in the music, rather than sit all of it out.

Dave Barnhart

Profile picture for user Aaron Blumer
Aaron Blumer

Newdcbii wrote: Many modern…

Thu, 10/29/26

dcbii wrote: Many modern worship songs, even if they have a singable tune in a good key and great lyrics with good theology, have timing changes or note changes at different points in the song, etc.

Yes they do! I used to commonly see the complaint that old hymns are harder to sing than contemporary worship songs. This has not been my experience. It’s true that I have a bias—having grown up on ‘old hymns,’ but the church where I serve the last 5 years or so has introduced me to several old hymns I had never heard before or new ones structured like the old, along with a lot of more contemporary music. The hymn-structured ones are always easier to learn, easier to remember during the week, and quicker for the congregation to pick up.

A ministry I’ve had that I wasn’t expecting: We often take a contemporary song that is worth the effort and I’m asked to ‘simplify’ it. So it’s a new arrangement that has more predictable structure.

Which is the key: predictability. People need that when it’s a new song. They need it when it’s an old song they haven’t memorized. The structure should be mostly predictable.

I think a little surprise now and then is important though. So maybe the melody changes a little bit in one spot or there’s a longer hold before a chorus. But these have to be very few, and well signaled, or you will only confuse and distract people who were just trying to sing along.

dcbii wrote: if the song is regular enough.

Yes. Predictability.

Where I’ll give a little bit of support to the ‘old hymns are harder’ cliche: many of them are too high. That certainly qualifies has greater difficulty. A second way they can be a little difficult is melodies and harmonies that follow idioms we rarely hear anymore. But the predictability mostly cancels out that one. You have a good idea of what’s coming and you can get used to the ‘not this century’ cadences pretty quickly.

‘Too high’ solution: I’m often on my own keyboard now. It sounds exactly like a piano, trust me, and feels exactly like one as well—but two quick key presses are all it takes to shift the instrument down (or up). And I use that regularly. We don’t have a band, so that doesn’t throw off any other instruments. If we had some, I’d just be telling them during the week: Plan to play this one in Eb rather than F or in D rather than C or vice versa. (Some contemporary songs are actually too low. Nobody can hit those G’s with anything like a strong hold. A passing G or two seems fine though.)

You don’t have to spend a fortune on a Nord to get a really good-sounding, easily transposable digital stage piano.

Also really like Dave’s idea of giving people copies of sheet music—at least a lead sheet, if nothing else. Maybe do it upon request or ‘sign up for this’ kind of thing. Because, in many churches, you only have a small few that can do anything with sheet music. But that handful of people can have a disproportionately positive effect on the singing of the whole body, because they are able to more confidently sing out and encourage others.

Our congregation definitely sings best when it’s a song we’ve sung a lot and in a consistent way. It also makes a big difference if the lyrics resonate with them and are a good pairing with the music.

There are some very able writers out there, but they do often seem to forget what congregations are like.

(For some context: When they’re meaty—or just superb at conveying a single powerful idea—I really enjoy the more complex contemporary music. It’s challenging to learn and sing, but I enjoy them more than the hymn-structured songs, on the whole. But congregational singing is not about what I enjoy more as a leader. It’s about the body, what we’re doing together, and what edifies.)

Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.

Profile picture for user dcbii
dcbii

NewAaron Blumer wrote: Also…

Thu, 10/29/26

Aaron Blumer wrote: Also really like Dave’s idea of giving people copies of sheet music—at least a lead sheet, if nothing else. Maybe do it upon request or ‘sign up for this’ kind of thing. Because, in many churches, you only have a small few that can do anything with sheet music.

My previous church was a good deal smaller than my current church, but they printed usually 5-10 copies of any new music for those who wanted it. You could pick it up next to the bulletin on the way in. Those who could use it were very appreciative. And to be honest, with that added, I had a lot less disappointment on finding out we were singing a new song. I’m pretty traditional, but some new songs are very good, and I love to learn them if I’m not just floundering the first few times they are sung.

Dave Barnhart

Profile picture for user Don Johnson
Don Johnson

Newon reading music

Thu, 10/29/26

I had two years of piano (the great tribulation!!) and my teacher was very good at also teaching me some basics of theory. So I can follow the basic ideas the notes represent, up or down, hold a bit longer or a bit shorter.

With experience, I think many church members can grasp that much even without the rudimentary training I had. Thus, I am an advocate of hymnals in general. And I don't like a lot of new music. Developing a congregational repertoire (largely based in the hymnal) is more important to me.

Maranatha!
Don Johnson
Jer 33.3

Profile picture for user JDen
JDen

NewHybrid

Fri, 10/30/26

At our church, all the songs we use are from our hymnal, but we also put them on our screen. But not just the lyrics; we put the full music notation on the screen for every song. That, I think, removes the best objections that I've heard against using screens for congregational singing, which is what Don noted here, the value of being able to follow the notes. It is a bit of work each week, but it seems worth it as it allows some of our older members, young mothers, etc. to not have to hold a heavy hymnal and generally seems to increase the volume of the congregation since we're singing out instead of down.

Profile picture for user dcbii
dcbii

NewNotes on screen

Mon, 11/02/26

At our church, all the songs we use are from our hymnal, but we also put them on our screen. But not just the lyrics; we put the full music notation on the screen for every song.

Speaking as one of the “older members” you referred to, I heartily applaud this. I’ve been to one other church that did this, though one of the members told me they only do it for “new” songs, though it wasn’t clear how long a song was considered to be new. I’m old enough to love and prefer hymnals, but projecting the notes certainly works for me, particularly if any non-hymnal songs are used.

Dave Barnhart

Profile picture for user Bert Perry
Bert Perry

NewAs a sometime song-leader...

Mon, 11/02/26

I do like the lyrics with the notes, but when I'm up front, the spotlights make it difficult to see the notes. (come on, guys, does the congregation really need to see me that clearly? Ha!)

Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.

Profile picture for user Don Johnson
Don Johnson

In reply to Hybrid by JDen

NewJDen wrote: At our church,…

Mon, 11/02/26

JDen wrote:

At our church, all the songs we use are from our hymnal, but we also put them on our screen. But not just the lyrics; we put the full music notation on the screen for every song. That, I think, removes the best objections that I've heard against using screens for congregational singing, which is what Don noted here, the value of being able to follow the notes. It is a bit of work each week, but it seems worth it as it allows some of our older members, young mothers, etc. to not have to hold a heavy hymnal and generally seems to increase the volume of the congregation since we're singing out instead of down.

not being able to read the notes is not all that I was objecting to.

In addition, I have seen projections of the musical notation, but it is often just the melody, which isn't enough.

My biggest objection is the over-use of many new songs which the congregation just doesn't know, notes or no notes. The hymnal creates a local church repertoire where repeated use builds familiarity and better singing.

I'm not against the concept as a concept, but I think overall quality of singing in most churches is not all that great, especially on the many new songs.

Finally, on the increase of volume - I have heard of studies of this that show no appreciable difference, especially when you are within the congregation itself. Maybe the song leader hears a difference, as he is on the receiving end of the singing, but I'm not sure anyone else does.

Maranatha!
Don Johnson
Jer 33.3

Profile picture for user pvawter
pvawter

NewI found this panel…

Tue, 11/03/26

I found this panel discussion very helpful, especially as it concerns song selection and how to introduce new songs to the congregation. Dr. Burgraff's comments on song shelf life and how many times you have to sing a new song are excellent.

https://youtu.be/z5yCxEdeIk0?t=984&is=KfBuLhB8aW2jgP7s

Profile picture for user JDen
JDen

In reply to JDen wrote: At our church,… by Don Johnson

NewHarmony and hymnals

Wed, 11/04/26

Don Johnson wrote: not being able to read the notes is not all that I was objecting to.

In addition, I have seen projections of the musical notation, but it is often just the melody, which isn't enough.

My biggest objection is the over-use of many new songs which the congregation just doesn't know, notes or no notes. The hymnal creates a local church repertoire where repeated use builds familiarity and better singing.

Agreed on all of this. I've had people in our church suggest that we only put the melody on the screen (it'd be easier, after all) and others suggesting that since we have the screen, that opens up the possibility of us using more songs beyond just the hymnal. I've resisted both suggestions. In theory, there is nothing wrong with adding some good songs that aren't in the hymnal, but then it becomes the norm and there isn't a limited repertoire anymore (our hymnal already has some 400 songs; that's already a lot more than we can actually sing with any regularity).

Related . . .

Topics: Hymnals, Congregational Singing, Hymns, Getty Music
  • The Sing! Hymnal: A Review
  • God Doesn’t Need Your Singing, but Your Neighbor Does
  • Moody and Gospel Hymns
  • Digital Hymnal Lifewayworship.com Will Live On
  • A plea for prioritizing the singing of familiar Christmas carols

Pagination

  • Page 1
  • Next page

Featured Resources

AU Logo

(About Amazon links)

Whoever restrains his words has knowledge, and he who has a cool spirit is a man of understanding.

(ESV, Proverbs 17:27)

Footer

  • About
  • Contact
  • Search
  • Forum

Since 2005

Image
2005 SI Logo Image