DVD Review - What's in the Bible?

[amazon B003C1RN0Y thumbnail]

[amazon B003C1RN0Y]

[amazon B003C1RN0Y binding]
[amazon B003C1RN0Y publisher]

My dad recently came home from a writers’ conference where he picked up a book and a new DVD for us to proof for our children. The book was entitled [amazon 1595551220] by the creator of Veggie Tales, Phil Vischer (more commonly known as the voice of Bob the Tomato). Before reading the book, I looked at the DVD case which was entitled . While I was cautiously excited that Phil Vischer had created a new company called Jelly Fish Labs, I was also concerned. It looked as if the series was going to be a really low-budget, thrown together show. Instead of computer animated characters It featured puppets that didn’t look especially engaging—at least to an adult. That wasn’t my only concern, however.

I confess that, more often than not, I am a Veggie Tales fan. I’ll even admit that I’ve watched Veggie Tales video without children present and have actually enjoyed the experience immensely. However, nobody has to see many episodes to realize that Veggie Tales is a bit lacking in spiritual depth. The show teaches good biblical principles to children in a creative, funny, and clean way that’s entertaining for everyone—so I am not complaining. I own many of the Veggie Tales stories and frequently hum some of Larry’s Silly Songs. Plus, Veggie Tales DVDs reinforce the values and principles that my wife and I are teaching our children—and our children really enjoy them. But, honestly, how much insight into Scripture could my kids really glean from a Bible-overview from the Veggie guy?

I should have known better. I started to read Phil’s book and soon found myself immersed in a phenomenal autobiography about the rise, fall, bankruptcy, and sale of Phil’s company, “Big Idea.” The book detailed the lessons that Phil learned about business, leadership, and most importantly, his walk with the Lord through the whole experience. I’ll avoid giving too much attention to the book here and just say that I found myself eager to watch the DVD. So, my wife, two boys, and I all sat down as a family to watch this promising new show together. Wow! In the words of Larry the Cucumber, “I laughed! I cried! It moved me, Bob!” What my wife and I found was an engaging, biblically educational overview of the Bible put together in such a way that even I, as an adult, was enthralled. It was lighthearted and humorous, yet respectful and serious. Oh, and did I mention that the kids loved it too?

This new series will be broken up into a thirteen DVD overview of Scripture, two half hour episodes per DVD, with three DVDs already available for sale for about the same price as Veggie Tales DVDs. We used Christmas and our son’s birthday as an excuse to get the latest two. The fourth one will be released in September, and we are eagerly awaiting its arrival. The first DVD includes the series introduction and covers creation and most of Genesis. The second DVD covers the end of Genesis through the book of Exodus. The third DVD covers Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. The soon to be released DVD will be an overview of Joshua, Judges, and Ruth.

Practically everything in the show is put together by Phil. He does all the voices and performance of the puppets including the main character, Buck Denver (Man of news), explorers Clive and Ian, Sunday School Lady (and of course, her flannel graph), Pastor Paul, the cowboy Chuck Wagon, a kid named Michael in a car seat who is riding to his grandma’s house, and several others who all help us understand each section of the Bible. Phil also writes the script and much of the show’s very catchy music. What can I say? All those unsaved people who are so talented that you think, “If only they’d get saved, they could sure do a lot of good for the Lord with those gifts!”—Phil Vischer is one of those guys. He is a brilliantly gifted storyteller who is using his gifts for the glory of God.

The educational depth of the show surprised me as well. It’s not just an overview but gives biblical answers to great questions that kids frequently ask. What is a Bible anyway? Why is it important? Who wrote it? What are the different sections of the Bible (like poetry, history, epistles)? Even more impressive was the fact that the series deals with more in depth information about the Bible than I thought it would attempt to tackle. I mean, how many young kids do you know who have been exposed to biblical issues concerning why the Apocrypha isn’t included in the Bible, what the Pentateuch is, what the differences were between ritual and ethical laws in the Mosaic Law, when the Council of Nicaea occurred and what it was about, how we identified the canon, what the Septuagint was, and why the Dead Sea Scrolls were important? I was blown away that these deeper issues were addressed in such a way that elementary school children are able to pick them up. Most of these subjects also have catchy songs that work with them to reinforce what is being talked about. I, for one, can’t remember ever hearing a song when I was a kid about the difference between the ritual and ethical commands in the book of Leviticus.

One aspect I really appreciated was that the DVD introduced the subject of substitutionary atonement and “God’s big rescue plan” from our sin and rebellion against God. It explains the need for salvation (from the account of Adam and Eve), shows how we’re all infected by sin, and then how God began His rescue plan through Abraham, and subsequently through the children of Israel. It illustrates how God’s big rescue saves believers from the penalty of sin, the power of sin, and will one day save us from the presence of sin. The series traces the overarching story of redemption through the Old Testament, and I’m looking forward to seeing how they culminate it in the Gospels.

Not all aspects of the show are positive, and I certainly wouldn’t advocate using this series as the sole means of biblical education for your children! While I think it is a great educational tool far superior to anything Veggie Tales has ever put out, there are a couple of things that left me disappointed. In dealing with creation, Phil explains both the young earth view and the day age view and gives both of them equal weight. I understand why he does this, but I would have much preferred to see him refute the “millions of years” as false (he does explain both positions fairly). The way the issue was presented wasn’t a deal breaker for me in enjoying the series, but I did stop to explain to my children which view I believed to be correct and why.

The DVD also mentions that God inspired the writers’ thoughts and told them what to write, but allowed them to choose the words. It wasn’t clear if he holds to the ‘verbal plenary’ inspiration of Scripture, or if only the thoughts are inspired. One other note of caution is that Pastor Paul’s Protestant backwards collar may confuse some kids, though that wasn’t a problem for our family. One other point I was originally concerned about was that Phil would take a covenant theology view of the Old Testament. But the show doesn’t delve quite that deeply into that area of theology and identifies the old covenant simply as God’s promise to Israel—so, no worries there yet.

To sum up, What’s in the Bible is an engaging, witty, light hearted, entertaining, and very welcome addition to our DVD collection that I’m happy to let my children watch. It is a great springboard for family discussions that facilitate biblical instruction. I’m thankful that Phil Vischer is undertaking this work to help children understand the Bible.


Joe Leavell recently moved to Phoenix after serving as a senior pastor of a church in northern California for three years. He is pursuing a master’s degree in biblical counseling and is carefully and prayerfully considering the Lord’s leading for his family. He is the husband of Rebekah and the father of three children: Philip (7), Caleb (4), and Sophia (10 months).

Discussion

I appreciate your review, Bro. Leavell, and the clarifications you’ve made. I understand that a review doesn’t mean a wholesale recommendation across the board. I’m voicing my concerns about the trends I see in edutainment- especially Christian edutainment- more than I’m objecting to VeggieTales or Phil Vischer’s ministry specifically, so as you say- that premise would make a thread of its own.

I truly don’t expect every family to live in accordance with my own ideals, and I’m realistic about the challenges of teaching children the Word of God- I’ve spent this whole week in VBS teaching kids whose only knowledge of Noah is from Evan Almighty. Oy vey.

I do think there is one way to mix frivolity/humor with “serious doctrine.” As I’ve been thinking about what goes “clunk” in our VBS and what doesn’t, I’ve seen something of a pattern. Humor works well as a tool for exposing the flaws in human nature… our foolishness, etc. It’s true that sometimes humor can make serious flaws look unserious/unimportant so that category isn’t a no brainer either, but I’ve often found that a silly skit in which a character does something goofy that illustrates something true about the way people are doesn’t seem out of character or like a forced wedding between incompatible things.

Still struggling with ways to communicate this. But gettin’ there maybe.

Also, there is a difference between serious/unserious and important/unimportant. That is, we do not necessarily communicate that something is unimportant when we depict it in a humorous way. The long and glorious tradition (hmmm….Princess Bride) of parody kind of backs that up.

And sometimes laughter is such a powerful tool for getting folks to lower their defenses and consider a truth they would otherwise bristle at.

But I consistently find that it does not work at all to put Jesus suffering and death in a skit with whimsical fictional characters. It seems to either insult Jesus’ ordeal or make it seem unreal… or, if it properly honors Jesus’ suffering and death it immediately makes the fiction/humor in the thing evaporate. Some things are just too big to mix with things that are little.

But human foibles… they really are funny while often being tragic at the same time.

One example: I’ve only seen it maybe twice and don’t remember much detail, but the Veggie Tales vid about the Blueberry who has all the stuff she could possibly want but is miserable… it’s funny but sad at the same time. I think it works. It’s not a Bible story, so I like that about the vid, too… no risk of making a true story look like a fictional one.
[Scott Aniole] So they use puppets to teach Bible stories, never realizing that their children are learning to view biblical truth as something light and trivial.
Scott, I get what you’re saying and I think the idea that we are going for the mind at exactly the time we should be going for the affections is worth some serious reflection.

But I wonder if it’s so easy to tell what kids are learning. I grew up on this kind of stuff and I did not learn to “view biblical truth as something light an trivial.” Rather, I think that at least some of the time, the puppets—for example—were serious to me. What I see when I watch kids watch skits and things is that they suspend disbelief to a degree we adults are just not capable of. The puppet show becomes reality for them for a while.

So I often wonder if what goes “clunk” for me doesn’t work just fine for them after all. It’s not easy to sort out.

Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.

It’s hilarious and one of the best tools I’ve ever read to read the Old Testament always pointing to Jesus. Sally lloyd Jones makes the book funny to adults as you read them to kids (and funny to kids too).

I read the story of Joseph this past week to the kids at my church. I don’t think I’ll ever read the story the same way again. She concluded by saying that another Prince would come to save his own family, and other people as well. This Prince would be punished for things he didn’t do too, and save his people from all the bad stuff they do against God. I mean wow!

Sally and Phil should really get together.

I do enjoy Veggie Tales. Sometimes a three year old needs to be reminded that God is bigger than the boogie man, Godzilla or the Monsters on TV. When thinking about entertainment choices for kids I think: 1) does it do harm? 2) does it teach lessons of general help?

Veggie Tales is a bit lacking in spiritual depth. The show teaches good biblical principles to children in a creative, funny, and clean way that’s entertaining for everyone—so I am not complaining.
What would any of us say about a Preacher or Sunday School cirriculum who’s teaching lacked spriritual depth but taught good principals. Good principals divorced from spritual depth equals mere moralism, no?
Don’t forget the Jesus Storybook Bible It’s hilarious and one of the best tools I’ve ever read to read the Old Testament always pointing to Jesus.
How well can a book that’s a barrel of laughs truly help us understand a portion of scripture that generally isn’t one.

As to the VBS quandary, last night I sat in the opener section of our churchs VBS. Pirates dashed around the room collecting the worship of offerings which were then weighed on a scale to see who had given the most (in pounds and ounces anyway). All the while The William Tell Overture was being played on the piano. It is probably no coincidence that many parents of those children (and perhaps some parents here) don’t really know what Scott means above when he uses the terms “affections” and “moral imagination”. I had no idea myself until after reading alot of Bauder’s articles on imagination some of Scott’s work at Religious Affections. I confess I have yet to tackle the Jonathan Edwards work of the same title, but already my wife and I are rethinking things we and our church do.

To the point of humor and revealing human foibles, I agree humor can function that way. Even that can backfire, though. I sat through a workshop by a fairly famous Biblical counseling author (who can be hilarious) at a conference a few months ago. He used a couple very funny anecdotes to points up our sin problem. Then he attempted to help us reach a more serious conclusion, and everyone burst out laughing. He stopped and said, “You know its not really funny.” He was right, it wasn’t, but he kept wrenching us between comedy and theology. It wasn’t entirely the audiences fault.

Maybe this sounds like a screed. I hope not. But its something I’ve become very concerned with over the past few months.

I don’t personally think it’s possible for a regenerate person to receive mere moralism. Any time you teach a Spirit indwelt, reborn, adopted child of God (who is in the process of being remade in Christ’s image) right from wrong, you help him forward. How deep does “You shouldn’t lie” need to be?

But if we understand what DVD’s can never be (a complete spiritual diet), we can make good use of them as “dessert.”

Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.

[Shaynus] Don’t forget the Jesus Storybook Bible It’s hilarious and one of the best tools I’ve ever read to read the Old Testament always pointing to Jesus.
[DavidO] How well can a book that’s a barrel of laughs truly help us understand a portion of scripture that generally isn’t one.
David, the Jesus Storybook Bible is not intended to be funny at all. It’s a serious storybook Bible. Shaynus thinks it’s “hilarious” that every story in the OT points to Jesus.

-------
Greg Long, Ed.D. (SBTS)

Pastor of Adult Ministries
Grace Church, Des Moines, IA

Adjunct Instructor
School of Divinity
Liberty University

How deep does “You shouldn’t lie” need to be?
Deep enough to foster the understanding that all moral imperatives are based in the character of God. A child of three can begin to grasp that God tells us not to lie not because life will work better for us and others if we don’t, but because truth is a part of His nature.

Greg,

Thanks. Not familiar with that work, so I didn’t “get it”.

[Joseph Leavell]…One of the most effective ways to do so is the use of humor and ingenuity and this series uses those mediums for instruction, not using the Bible for the sake of entertainment (by the way, I like your thoughts on the differences between entertainment and enjoyment. That would make a good discussion on a thread). While I don’t believe humor is all bad but rather a gift from God when used to glorify Him, it more than certainly has become a dominant characteristic in our entertainment driven culture.
I decided to create a new thread to further pursue the topic of Christian ‘edutainment’- you’ll find it http://sharperiron.org/forum/thread-christian-edutainment] here . That way this thread can be preserved to discuss Phil Vischer’s series specifically.

Deep enough to foster the understanding that all moral imperatives are based in the character of God. A child of three can begin to grasp that God tells us not to lie not because life will work better for us and others if we don’t, but because truth is a part of His nature.
Fair enough. I’m pretty sure that point comes across in a couple of the Veggie vids I’ve seen. It’s a very easy one to make… though probably without the phrase “moral imperatives” :)

But I’m pretty sure the “life will work better” point is biblical as well.

Prov. 12.19

Prov. 21.6

Prov. 20:17

Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.