Skip to main content
SHARPER IRON
“As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.” (Proverbs 27:17)
  • About
    • About Sharper Iron
    • Doctrinal Statement
    • Contact
    • Search
  • Forum
    • Forum Home
    • Comment Guidelines
    • Search
  • Account
    • Log in
    • Register

The Moral Majority Failed

By C. D. Cauthorne Jr. on Fri, 11/20/26
Moral Majority
Religious Right
New Right
Image
Photo of Jerry Falwell at a 20th century event

Jerry Falwell at a July 4, 1776 celebration (Photo: George Smith, The News & Advance)

Following the massive Republican mid-term losses, I came across a 1970s Children’s Bible Hour album on YouTube. It featured “Uncle Charlie” and his kids joyfully singing about Jesus. As I listened, a thought came to me: What would our nation be like if there had been more Charlie VanderMeers preaching the Gospel and fewer Jerry Falwells promoting conservative politics?

In 1979, Pastor Jerry Falwell, Sr. founded the Moral Majority in response to the growing secularization and moral looseness in America. The organization

advanced conservative social values, notably opposing abortion, pornography, the ERA, and gay rights. In addition, the organization supported increased defense spending, a strong anti-communist foreign polity, and continued American support for Israel.1

One of the Moral Majority’s greatest critics was the fundamentalist Bob Jones University (BJU). In the September 1980 issue of BJU’s Faith for the Family, BJU President Bob Jones, III warned that the Moral Majority “holds more potential for hastening the church of Antichrist and building the ecumenical church than anything to come down the pike in a long time” since “the aim of the Moral Majority is to join together Catholics, Jews, Protestants of every stripe, Mormons, etc., in a common religious cause.”

Jones, III asserted that

cleaning up America’s morals is not the church’s mission. Preaching Christ is our mission. … Cleaning up America’s morals is nothing but sweeping the house clean of evil spirits, only to find that seven times more evil spirits fill it.

“The moral majority,” Jones, III continued, “implies to a nation under the curse of sin and in need of the regenerating power of Christ that if somehow it could plug the dike through which immorality flows into the country, America would become a good, decent place in which to live.” Furthermore, the Moral Majority

has sought to make [sinners] feel less guilty and more saintly and, thus, makes them further from the reach of Christ, Who said, ‘I came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance’ (Luke 5:32). What this nation needs to feel is more sinful, not less. We need to feel the full force of God’s condemnation and our alienation from God. … We need the foundation of morality and self-righteousness stripped from those who claim it so that they might see themselves as the sinners they are before a holy God.

According to Jones, III, the Moral Majority would accomplish two devilish goals. First, it will infuse unbiblical ecumenism into Bible-believing Christianity. Second, it will plant a spirit of moral superiority within its followers which will keep them from a genuine relationship with God that is only available to sinners.

In a letter addressed to the “BJU ‘Preacher Boy’” dated June 10, 1980, BJU Chancellor Bob Jones, Jr. added a third negative consequence of the Moral Majority – a minimization of sin. In his letter, Jones, Jr. recalled Falwell, Sr.’s public introduction of U. S. Senate candidate John Warner’s wife in 1978:

Any man who in the middle of a crusade for morality and the home will introduce the muchmarried Elizabeth Taylor to his congregation on Sunday morning and to his television audience raises serious doubts about how genuinely concerned he is about moral standards. Elizabeth Taylor is a perfect example of the thing that he is supposed to be crusading against. He should have denounced her, not promoted her and given her the aura of respectability.2

Over 45 years have passed since the founding of the Moral Majority. It folded in 1989. Was the Moral Majority a success, or were its critics correct?

In the short term, the Moral Majority successfully helped elect Ronald Reagan as President in 1980. However, from that point on, Evangelical social issues were wedded to a strong national defense and free market economics—the conservative cause. Republicans began gravitating toward the pro-life position, while Democrats became pro-choice. Before the Moral Majority, there were a number of prominent pro-life Democrats;3 abortion was not a partisan issue.

Today, most Republicans reluctantly oppose abortion. Although Republican-appointed judges overturned the pro-abortion Roe v. Wade Supreme Court ruling, abortion rates are rising4 in America because the Trump administration refuses to revoke the FDA’s approval of the “abortion pill” and enforce the Comstock Act.

The fruits of the Moral Majority fully ripened in 2016 when Jerry Falwell, Jr. endorsed Donald Trump for President. This occurred as Falwell, Jr. was secretly working with Trump’s “fixer” Michael Cohen to keep racy pictures of his wife from being released5—pictures related to Falwell, Jr.’s wife’s affair with a Florida pool boy.6 Hollywood’s morality, once glossed over by Falwell, Sr., had infiltrated the heart of his bibulous son. Falwell, Sr. did not consider the long-term effects that ignoring immorality for political prominence would have on his flock and family.

Eternal pursuits never perish; earthly pursuits always perish. When descent-sounding Democrats such as James Talarico, Adam Hamilton, and Annie Andrews ran against deeply-flawed Republicans, they won. The American people finally tired of hypocritical Republicans and their immoral, foul-mouthed, sacrilegious Head who made unfulfilled promises of peace and cheaper prices.

Wicked Babylon—this evil world’s system—will only collapse when Christ returns (Rev. 18:1-19:6). Instead of joining futile efforts to redeem Babylon, we should emulate the likes of “Uncle Charlie” by carrying out Christ’s Great Commission: “Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you; and, lo, I am with you always, even unto the end of the world” (Matt. 28:19-20). Regeneration, not reformation and legislation, is the uniquely Christian answer to the sinful mess society finds itself in today.

Notes

1 https://www.britannica.com/topic/Moral-Majority

2 file:///C:/Users/calva/Downloads/p17184coll1_1766.pdf

3 https://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/the-future-of-the-pro-life-democrat

4 https://www.guttmacher.org/fact-sheet/induced-abortion-united-states

5 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/jerry-falwell-jr-sought-michael-cohen-s-help-preventing-racy-n1003096

6 https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2022/01/inside-jerry-falwell-jr-unlikely-rise-and-precipitous-fall?srsltid=AYCX9vJ2_SuTuT7N48E4SwlY6MqrsbOAKRdZTxw8Rh3cBHvsN0kJPVEg

C. D. Cauthorne Bio

C. D. Cauthorne Jr. earned his BA and MA at Bob Jones University during the 1990s. He and his wife Heather serve at Calvary Baptist Church near Clintwood, Virginia, where C. D. is pastor.

Discussion

Profile picture for user Aaron Blumer
Aaron Blumer

NewYes and no

Fri, 11/20/26

Agree that MM was not “a success” in any enduring sense. Success depends a lot on what the objective is. To the degree the objective was “to advance…” the case could be made it was indeed a success. It advanced things it set out to advance.

Was its goal to enduringly transform? I don’t know. If it was, then yes, it failed.

C. D. Cauthorne Jr. wrote: The fruits of the Moral Majority fully ripened in 2016 when Jerry Falwell, Jr. endorsed Donald Trump for President. This occurred as Falwell, Jr. was secretly working with Trump’s “fixer” Michael Cohen to keep

I have to push back on that part.

Things would have gone quite differently in 2016 if the MM had “fully ripened,” but it did not. Trumpism was a repudiation of the whole idea of ‘moral.’ In it’s place, it embraced ‘winning.’ It had nothing to do with the MM, other than that Liberty Univ and a guy also named Falwell were also part of the new right (probably not the biggest part) that embraced the folly of Trumpism.

I’ve been saying since 2016 and probably before, that winning doesn’t count for much if you abandon all that you were supposedly about in order to win.

A little parable just occurred to me.

A guy wanted to win a race. As he fell behind his competitors, he realized he needed to grow lighter in order to win. So he cut off a hand. Soon he was in the pack again and nearing the front, but then began to lag again. So he cut off a whole arm. This cycle continued until, finally, he found that he needed to jettison his soul. It was just getting in the way and slowing him down. So just as he reached the finish line, he breathed his last, abandoned his soul and died. He fell across the line, the “winner.”

(Yeah, I know, how did he cut more off once both hands were gone… and how did he keep running without legs…? Don’t overthink it! )

Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.

Related . . .

Topics: Evangelicals, Christian Right, Moral Majority, Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson
  • Review: "The Evangelicals" by Frances Fitzgerald

More by C. D. Cauthorne Jr.

  • The Rise and Fall of Kenny Baldwin
  • Staying Together for the Kids’ Sake
  • Review of Brian Recker’s ‘Hell Bent: How the Fear of Hell Holds Christians Back from a Spirituality of Love’
  • Chris Anderson’s “The Scandal of Schism” – A Review
  • BJU: Can’t Beat the Real Thing

Pagination

  • Page 1
  • Next page

Featured Resources

AU Logo

Cover Image

View at Amazon


(About Amazon links)

It is honorable for a man to stop striving, Since any fool can start a quarrel.

(NKJV, Proverbs 20:3)

Footer

  • About
  • Contact
  • Search
  • Forum

Since 2005

Image
2005 SI Logo Image