The Irreconcilable Pursuit of Christ & Coolness (Part 2)
Image
From VOICE, July/Aug 2015. Used with permission. Read Part 1.
The Bible & Coolness
How should we live as Christians in a culture that is driven by style and worships the cult of youth, popularity, and appearances? A culture where the greatest fear seems to be becoming old-fashioned, out of date, passé?
Solomon’s words in Ecclesiastes echo through the generations. There is no new thing (Ecclesiastes 1:9-10); we only forget what has come before (Ecclesiastes 1:11). We are born rebels (Ephesians 2:1-3), yet each new generation that rebels believes its insurrection is novel. Seeking to set ourselves apart from the majority, to impress the world with our unique style and way of living, is part of our fallen human nature.
Here’s something else to consider. There’s a very good reason why churches and Christianity, and indeed Christians, tend not to be noted by the world for their trendiness. The problem with trying to make Christianity fashionable is Christ Himself. He said in John 15:18-19
If the world hates you, know that it has hated me before it hated you. If you were of the world, the world would love you as its own; but because you are not of the world, but I chose you out of the world, therefore the world hates you.
Jesus is warning us about a harsh reality: as long as we follow the Jesus of the Bible, the world will hate us no matter how cool we try to be … because we represent Him and He represents righteousness, accountability and judgment. Watch how any Christian, no matter how attractive or winsome or popular, is treated by the media when speaking out in the name of Christ. It gets ugly in a hurry.
Christ Himself very specifically and deliberately welcomed the least cool of His world. He consciously reached out to the most socially unappealing, to those with the least outward attractiveness and social status. Jesus was for misfits and outsiders, for those mocked, rejected or overlooked by others. He had total compassion on all those who were excluded or looked down on by society for being “uncool” or weird or odd; those who didn’t fit.
He didn’t exclude them and He doesn’t tolerate our exclusion of them today. The church exists for such as these: for the least, the unlovely, the social outcasts and outsiders all of whom God has called, according to 1 Corinthians 1:26-29.
I’m certainly not saying that Jesus loves you more if you’re some kind of nerd or weirdo. Nor am I advocating an unfashionable appearance. I don’t think we need to deliberately try to make ourselves or our church embarrassing or uncool, any more than we need to deliberately go out looking for suffering. What I am saying is that we’d better make sure our churches aren’t too cool and too sophisticated to include the weirdos, oddballs and socially awkward. And we had better make sure our churches follow God’s pattern for us regardless of whether the world approves or not.
As Paul said in 1 Corinthians 4:13, “We have become, and are still, like the scum of the world, the refuse of all things.” You can’t make Christianity cool without rebuilding it in your own image. Let’s not labor to make the world love us; instead let’s love them and shrug off any hatred they throw our way. Our faith sets us apart, and we should dare to be different as new creations in Christ.
Jesus told us we that we will face hardship and persecution for His name’s sake (Matthew 10:22-26, 34-39; Luke 21:16-17). Paul told Timothy that if you live a godly life, you will suffer persecution (2 Timothy 3:12). Peter said that we should expect to encounter fiery trials (1 Peter 4:12) and rejoice when we do (1 Peter 4:13-14), then entrust ourselves to our faithful God (v.19).
James also addresses trials, writing that we should consider it joy when those hardships come (James 1:2-3). In Hebrews 13:13 we are instructed to go to Christ, outside the camp, bearing His reproach which is the exact opposite of seeking popularity! The Bible issues a clear and decisive call for mature and selfless sacrifice from those who know Christ as Savior, rejecting the love of the world.
Being a devoted follower of Jesus Christ has never been and will never be considered socially popular. But we don’t follow Christ to fit in with the “in crowd” or to find acceptance. We follow Christ because He died for our sins and as His redeemed people, He has commanded that we follow Him in obedience. We are to be in the world but not of the world (1 John 2:15). In the world there’s a wisdom that is foolishness to God; we are to seek the wisdom of God, which the world considers foolish (1 Corinthians 1:18-25, 3:18-21).
We need to acknowledge that the pursuit of Christ and coolness is irreconcilable. Detached individualism, alienation from authority and outward rebellion are sins that have no place in the Christian’s life because these are things opposed to Christ’s sovereign rule in our lives. They tend to cause self-centeredness and elitism (“I am superior to you because I am the arbiter of all things acceptably cool, things that are known only to me and my friends and obviously not to you”). Condescension is not Christian—humility is, along with a godly sense of community, respect, family and love.
Conclusion
The culture of the world is always changing. The cat’s pajamas. He’s a dreamboat. That’s just swell. Groovy. Far out. He’s the bomb. Phat. It’s so dope. The phrases of popular culture have a limited shelf life and the wrong words can mark you as a fossil from some forgotten decade.
Doesn’t that prove the point that we should resist being driven by ever changing fads and trends? One day you too will be an old-timer, hopelessly out of fashion, so why pretend otherwise? Why not obey the Bible’s commands to walk with wisdom and seek maturity, to be like Christ and not like whoever is the cultural icon of your day.
McCracken believes this mindset and lifestyle of “Wannabe-Cool Christianity” has become
far too accommodating and accepting of sin, something that should actually shock and disturb us. If it’s uncool to draw lines about what behavior is permissible and prudent for the Christian, then Christians should start getting used to the idea of being uncool.1
Amen to that.
Another series of warnings come from David Wells. In his book The Courage to Be Protestant, he writes:
The born-again, marketing church has calculated that unless it makes deep, serious cultural adaptations, it will go out of business, especially with the younger generations. What it has not considered carefully enough is that it may well be putting itself out of business with God.2
That’s a serious consideration!
And Wells asks these sobering questions.
What is the binding authority on the church? What determines how it thinks, what it wants, and how is it going to go about its business? Will it be Scripture alone, Scripture understood as God’s binding address, or will it be culture? Will it be what is current, edgy, and with-it? Or will it be God’s Word, which is always contemporary because its truth endures for all eternity?3
He asks—is it Sola Scriptura or Sola Cultura?
Wells is right when he asserts that a careful biblical theology must undergird the local church’s ministry if it will be rightly related to Christ. But many churches are neglecting the Bible and traditional doctrine. It’s not that these churches
want to deny it or reject it, but it is something of an embarrassment to them. At least in their own churches, they want to conceal it. They want it hidden, kept in the background, made to disappear from what they are doing. It is rather like a family secret. Family secrets are true, but they should be kept private. They should not be divulged.4
Then Wells observes:
Everywhere in the marketing approach [type of churches] theology and Bible knowledge are downplayed, and then we are dumbfounded when commitment evaporates and ignorance reigns! The gelding is castrated, as C.S. Lewis observed in another context, and yet we expect it to be fruitful.5
Let’s not be embarrassed of Christ and His Word, hiding His teachings lest we be exposed as His followers, trying to make Christ’s commandments acceptable to the skeptical world through a veil of coolness. Let’s resolve never to lose God’s blessing—to be “put out of business with God,” as Wells wrote—in the irreconcilable pursuit of both Christ and coolness.
Les Lofquist Bio
Les Lofquist earned his BA at Grace College, and his MDiv at Grace Theological Seminary. Over his years of ministry, he has served as a missionary church planter, Bible college instructor, youth pastor and senior pastor. He has served as Executive Director of IFCA since 1999. He and his wife Miriam have been blessed with several children and grandchildren.
- 9 views
Am looking forward to (I hope) future installments and more discussion. One question that comes to mind is what kind of “gut checks” we ought to use to establish whether we are trying too hard to be cool, and also what we might do to replace trying to be cool. One thing that comes to mind for me is to think of how to do things well in a Biblical fashion.
Obviously I would open a whole can of worms about how to define that, but hey, let’s go fishing, no?
Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.
I feel strange as I read this. I don’t do anything to try to be “cool” or “hip” at church.
- We’re in a small, very old building with stained glass windows. This is an old, country church.
- We have pews that actually look like pews - this place cannot be mistaken for anything other than a church building.
- We sing from a hymnal.
- We do Scripture readings before the morning service.
- All the musical accompaniment we have is a piano and a temperamental organ.
- Perhaps the “coolest” thing we have is a 55-in flatscreen in from of the platform where I use PowerPoint to accompany my preaching. I put the verses up there as we march through a passage, and throw in a few graphics and visual illustrations as I need to. Wow.
- I preach in an expository way, verse by verse, book by book. Poor Andy Stanley would be scandalized. We’ve been on the Gospel of John since January 2014, and am just about finished. We’re starting Hebrews next. We’re doing Lamentations in the afternoon, and will move to Esther after that. We just finished Ephesians for Sunday School, and am in Acts now.
We don’t do anything to be deliberately cool. Maybe we’re not being “relevant” enough for some people, but it seems fine to me.
Tyler is a pastor in Olympia, WA and works in State government.
Very good and to the point!
"The Midrash Detective"
reference to 2 Corinthians 4:13 should be to 1 Corinthians 4:13
[Doug Flynn]reference to 2 Corinthians 4:13 should be to 1 Corinthians 4:13
Fixed. Thanks for pointing that out.
Dave Barnhart
This one (in two parts) really resonated with me as well… I do often see in churches generally an effort to disguise Christianity as a nifty new philosophy of life rather than an ancient way of life based on an ancient Book… a set of timeless answers to the unchanging realities of the human condition and the character of God.
But we live in a passionately “progressive” culture… so there is always this drive for something “newer and better” deeply driving us. We forget that all the really big questions have never changed—nor have all the best answers.
Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.
Just an observation: I find myself routinely dealing with “cool” at every level; therefore, I tend to think that chasing cool is more narcissistic than rebellious. Rebellion certainly comes into play, but only as a useful tool in the attempt to garner the desired attention from whatever target audience is involved. As I said, just an observation.
Lee
in our town, we are the “uncool” church, and while I’m not proud of that, the issue is a lot more of a pride issue to me than it is of rebellion, though it can be that; or narcissism. We want to think we are special, that we have the “it factor” that others do not have. That we are recipients of the grace of God in a “special” way that others are not. Isn’t it really a form of pride?
[Steve Newman]in our town, we are the “uncool” church, and while I’m not proud of that, the issue is a lot more of a pride issue to me than it is of rebellion, though it can be that; or narcissism. We want to think we are special, that we have the “it factor” that others do not have. That we are recipients of the grace of God in a “special” way that others are not. Isn’t it really a form of pride?
^^^^^^^^^^^THIS^^^^^^^^^^^^
[Steve Newman]in our town, we are the “uncool” church, and while I’m not proud of that, the issue is a lot more of a pride issue to me than it is of rebellion, though it can be that; or narcissism. We want to think we are special, that we have the “it factor” that others do not have. That we are recipients of the grace of God in a “special” way that others are not. Isn’t it really a form of pride?
Can be, but whether it’s pride in the Biblical sense really depends on our response to God’s grace? None of us can get around the fact that for whatever reason, God showed us His grace. We can either boast in Him, or we can think it’s of ourselves, and that’s all the difference.
Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.
Words like “coolness” and “trendiness” are just to vague.
I was probably one of the earliest adopters of a pastor having a computer (TRS-80 Model 3) back in June of 1982. It caused quite a stir in our large church (where I was an assistant Pastor) as a rumor that I had a record of everyone’s financial giving could seemingly not be quashed. (I actually used the high powered machine with 48 kb of memory and 2 floppies to maintain visitor records and print mailing labels of the same).
The first pastor with a:
- IPhone
- IPad (or preached from an IPad … horrors!)
- MacBook
- Blog
Was trendy and cool.
The first church in a community with air conditioning and padded pews was trendy and cool.
I had one, too. And a tape recorder data storage system!
I agree with Jim that “cool” and “trendy” are vague terms.
I remember when microphones, over head projectors, screens, guitars (in any venue), refreshments, community groups, and preaching without a tie were condemned (and I mean condemned) as signs of worldliness.
"Some things are of that nature as to make one's fancy chuckle, while his heart doth ache." John Bunyan
[Ron Bean]I agree with Jim that “cool” and “trendy” are vague terms.
I remember when microphones, over head projectors, screens, guitars (in any venue), refreshments, community groups, and preaching without a tie were condemned (and I mean condemned) as signs of worldliness.
I was led to Christ by a group that used all of these except for the microphone—and even that was used in some circumstances. I’m glad they were so worldly. I seem to remember as well Someone who did not wear a tie when He preached, given that it wouldn’t be invented for over a millenium afterwards. Twelve of his buddies did the same. Was that a community group no less? And it was awesome when they helped out at parties.
Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.
“Cool” for the purposes of the article is well defined in the piece. It’s not one in place in definition form… but it’s scattered throughout. You just have to make a few inferences.
… I really don’t know how it could be overlooked.
Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.
Discussion