Skip to main content
SHARPER IRON
“As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.” (Proverbs 27:17)
  • About
    • About Sharper Iron
    • Doctrinal Statement
    • Contact
    • Search
  • Forum
    • Forum Home
    • Comment Guidelines
    • Search
  • Account
    • Log in
    • Register

False Logic: The Folly of Claiming the NT Is Needed to Rightly Interpret the OT (Part 3)

By Paul Henebury on Mon, 10/26/26
Hermeneutics
Old Testament
Progressive Revelation
Series - NT for OT
Image
Photo of Hebrew Old Testament open to Isaiah

Read the series.

The doctrine of the sufficiency of Scripture is probably the most abused of all the doctrines of Biblical Christianity. As the Word of God, the only Word from outside the human realm, it ought to be cherished, adhered to and followed.

But even within the borders of so-called “Christendom” the Bible is hardly allowed a position of absolute authority. Seldom is it permitted the power of veto, particularly when, in our narcissistic society, its truths and precepts go against our preferences.

We can see this in the insistences of Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy that Scripture cannot stand alone; that it must be supported by the interpretations and musings of councils and spiritual thinkers of the remote past. Or the subtler challenges which take the shape of subjective experience that somehow gain the authority to put in the shade those inspired passages that would call us to repent of our consumerist approach to the Church.

And then there is the approach which looks at an OT covenant, or examines a prophetic promise, and simply decides that it cannot mean what it says. No, due to what is supposedly said later on in the Holy Scriptures, that is, in the NT, the oaths that God took are recast into types, transformed into adumbrations, and muted by being forced through the filter of genre, emerging dutifully to fit the notions of those who claim to be in subjection to them.

The claim that the NT must be used to interpret, or more accurately reinterpret the OT, gets its persuasive power from the truth that God had more to say than what He said in the Hebrew Scriptures. The advent of Jesus Christ, His death and resurrection, the birth of the Church: these were undoubtedly further revelations. But the coming of Christ was predicted in the OT (e.g., Gen. 3:15; Deut. 18:15-19; Psa. 22; Mic. 5:2; Isa. 7:14, 9:6; 53:1-12; 61:1-2a; Zech. 9:9), and not by means of shadowy quatrains and esoteric understandings. The Prophets gave us a realistic picture and Jesus pointed His detractors to it (Jn. 5:39-40).

But the picture was not to the liking of many believers, who, in the absence of Israel from their land, and in the presence of the NT Church, made their theologies robustly stand against the literal fulfillment of God’s promises to Israel and Jerusalem. Everything had to fit the reality of the Church. The Church was God’s people. That was it! Jeremiah 31:1-14, 31-37; 32:36-44, and 33:14-26? Easy. These promises of the Almighty were subordinated to Matthew 21:43; John 10:16; Romans 2:28-29, 9:8; Galatians 6:16 and 1 Peter 2:9-10, suitably interpreted, and turned into foreshadowings of the true Israel, the Church. Ezekiel’s Temple? Not the literal one in chapter 10, but that enormous unbelievable one in Ezekiel 40-48. Well, those heavily detailed chapters can be collapsed into the symbolic representation of the Church, of course. Hey, nevermind using the NT to reinterpret the OT, you could use the NT to reinterpret itself! Jesus’ promise to the disciples about them judging Israel in the regeneration? That’s the Church. The careful enumeration of the Twelves Tribes of Israel in Revelation 7:4-8? They are the same as the innumerable multitude from every nation revealed “after these things” in Revelation 7:9-10—Voila!, the Church.

Employing the dictum that the OT must be interpreted by the NT sure results in a great deal of transmutation of the seemingly lucid statements of the OT into obscure types and shadows awaiting the early Church’s ability to get ahold of a full NT in order to decipher them. And that is really the big problem with the whole idea. Not only is this pious sounding claim a distraction from their question-begging method of reading their theological assumptions into the OT. Not only was it an impossible task for the early Christians to accomplish with their piecemeal extracts of the NT Books available to them, but when their preferred interpretations of the NT are used to interpret the OT, the OT loses its character as inspired understandable revelation. It becomes the NT’s doormat, unable to tell us anything without the NT interrupting and rudely declaring “When the OT says that, it really means this.” And we who think that God expresses Himself just as plainly in the OT as He does in the NT are looked upon as dolts who have to be told over and over “The NT must interpret the OT!”

We have to take a deep cleansing breath. And then we need to assert and keep asserting that the OT is just as clear and authoritative as the NT and the two work together much better if the voices of spiritualizing, typologizing and genre-izing are muted. Then something wonderful happens. The voices of the two Testaments speak in harmony; neither one dictating to the other. Both being allowed to say what they say. Then the several strands of God’s amazing Creation Project reveal themselves as the OT and the NT reinforce each other.

All of Scripture is sufficient. But only when men listen to it, learn from it, and leave it alone to say what it plainly says, regardless of our tastes or presuppositions.

Dr Reluctant Articles

Reposted from Dr. Reluctant.

Paul Henebury Bio

Paul Martin Henebury is a native of Manchester, England and a graduate of London Theological Seminary and Tyndale Theological Seminary (MDiv, PhD). He has been a Church-planter, pastor and a professor of Systematic Theology and Apologetics. He was also editor of the Conservative Theological Journal (later Journal of Dispensational Theology). He is now the President of Telos School of Theology.

Discussion

Profile picture for user Aaron Blumer
Aaron Blumer

NewClashes of concepts vs clashes of communication

Sun, 10/25/26

Based on the back and forth on this here and elsewhere, I think it’s too difficult to debate an abstraction/generalization like whether we need NT to interpret OT. It seems that the core of the problem is some particular ways people use the NT to interpret the OT. As is illustrated here and earlier in the series.

Though the glib “isn’t it obvious that we should use the NT to interpret the OT?” as a defense for these ‘particular ways’ is annoying, to be sure.

About sufficiency, I think we should face something on that: for all of us, absolute authority of Scripture is an ideal, not a 100% reality. That doesn’t mean degrees of failure are all the same, but we all fail—even when we’re trying. And we are not always trying. Because we still sin, are still less than fully sanctified, and also are weak and foolish. I am not inclined to accuse people who arrive at different conclusions of not really honoring the authority of Scripture. Well, not usually. There are egregious cases of course, even among evangelicals.

I struggle with the logic of the main question (the need of NT to interpret OT) for a few reasons: For one, as others have noted, as generalizations go, we today need all of Scripture to understand all of Scripture. So there is no part that we can reliably get right without all of it. It’s all contextual. And we’re far removed from the moment of revelation and that setting.

And we, in fact, do have all of it and should use all of it, right?

But I do share a lot of Paul’s gripes about how OT promises are seemingly casually put through a blender in many cases to churchize them. It just seems doubtful to me that general rules about what must or must not be used to interpret what are really the issue. I’m open to being convinced, but I’m not there yet.

Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.

Profile picture for user Bert Perry
Bert Perry

NewWhat we might say

Mon, 10/26/26

I am going to start by admitting that I think I'm on dangerous ground in some ways here, but it strikes me that back in Bible times, there were certain things that people would automatically understand about the context of the Old Testament that we don't "get" today--at least not easily. So we might argue that the New Testament can at points "flesh out" what the Torah, history, and prophets are actually saying.

Such a contention is dangerous, of course, because the Old Testament records any number of places where the ancient Israelites emphatically did not understand (or respect) large portions of God's Word, and the New Testament indicates clearly that both the Pharisees and Sadducees also did not understand implications of the Old Testament, choosing instead to implement their own systems of serving God--or not.

But then, Jesus rebukes the Pharisees and Sadducees by pointing to Moses and the like as if it were obvious--He is using the doctrine of perspicuity, IMO. So that, along with the reality that the early church could not appeal to the Gospels, epistles, and the like before they were written, does emphasize that God did intend--at least with the assistance of His Spirit--there to be a lot of perspicuity to the Old Testament.

Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.

Profile picture for user Aaron Blumer
Aaron Blumer

NewSome distinctions get…

Tue, 10/27/26

Some distinctions get conflated a lot in these kinds of discussions.

One of them is the difference between what was understood and what could have been understood. But there is a third option, I think, what would be likely to be understood. But I think all three focus too much on the subjective human side of the transaction.

There’s a Revealer and an audience. What really matters is not what the audience did or should have understood (though that matters, too, yes), but what did the Revealer reveal?

I don’t personally see any problem with the notion that God as Revealer communicated truth that was neither understood nor even fully understandable at the time.

I’m willing also to say that God may have revealed truth that was very likely to be misunderstood, given human nature etc. I can’t think of an example, but I don’t see any reason to rule that out. However, I think we’re safe in assuming that the original audience mattered to God or He would not have spoken at all. So there was something He always intended to be understood.

But it doesn’t seem likely to me, looking at what’s there and what the NT does with it, that He intended to be fully understood all of the time. One of the things God clearly reveals about Himself in the OT is that He is not like us in a lot of ways, including he He unfolds His plans over time. And He is also clear that He is not telling us everything. Moses wants to see God’s glory. God says I’m not showing you that. But I’ll show you something residual. Deut 29.29, Moses speaking prophetically in that setting, gives us the mind of God. There are “secret things.”

And Paul famously speaks of ‘mysteries’ revealed to the apostles.

So nobody really denies that OT revelation was “incomplete” or “partial,” right? Is that debated? Well, if your Jewish of course. But among Christians, can I put that in the points of agreement column?

Where things start to get difficult is at another point of distinction often conflated: partial information vs. wrong information. Numbers 23.19. Revelation is never false.

Here where is where where non-subscribers to “covenant theology”—CT— (dispensationalists, biblical covenantalists, etc.) get, rightly I think, hot and bothered: CT has a ‘reversals’ problem. I’m not read up enough in CT to say a lot about this other than, from excerpts and reviews and so on, it certainly seems like CT at various points has the NT taking revelation in OT times and turning it into falsehood. They wouldn’t say it that way, not quite, but by logical inference, it seems hard to escape.

Where CT, I’m either vaguely remembering or just imagining, would push back is that God didn’t say “A is true” in OT times then in NT say “not A is true.” Rather, He was misunderstood.

The counter-counter I’m pretty sure I’ve read lots of times is at least two-fold: a) What could God reasonably have been expected to have meant originally? and b) isn’t it more respectful of revelation and the Revealer—and also simpler—to, wherever possible, take the position that if God plainly said “A is true” in the OT, He is not saying “not A is true” in the New? (It’s only because there is a human-derived logical grid called CT that we’re trying to get a ‘not A’ in these NT passages. Remove the burden of serving that grid and a lot of things fall into place just fine.)

Hence, the nutshell: let’s not make the NT necessary to understand the OT.

I think I have this summarized mostly right.

It’s super easy though, for both sides, to lose track of the context of the debate and get confused about what we’re affirming and denying about earlier revelation vs. later revelation. So I’m not in favor of nutshelling the debate in terms of what testament is doing what to what other testament.

To me, it comes down to good ol’ Occam’s Razor. What is the least complicated and most harmonious way to read the progress of revelation from original audiences to NT apostolic ones?

It doesn’t help a ton to ask “What would they have been likely to have understood God to mean?” because humans are likely to understand what they want to understand and vice versa. Better: “What, assuming willing and submitted hearts, would they have been likely to have understood God to mean?” Still, not great, I don’t think. But we don’t even need that angle, do we? The most egregious examples—from my limited exposure to the debate—seem to involve passages that are more like “How could anyone possibly have been expected to understand that God meant the near opposite of what He said?” I don’t know how many of the controversial passages are in that category, but some certainly seem to be. At any rate, non-CTers have cited passages they believe to be in that category—and they seem to correct, at least some of the time. And the category is so deep into the ‘obviousness’ zone that it doesn’t seem to be a difference of ‘degree of clarity.’ It’s a qualitative difference between ‘saying something somewhat mysterious’ and ‘saying something not in the least mysterious.’

I don’t know if that helps anyone, but it’s how the question strikes me right now. I don’t believe CT intends to make God a liar or even a bit sneaky. But I also see why non-CTers think they have done that. I’ve read examples that seem weighty.

Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.

Related . . .

Topics: Perspicuity, Supersessionism, Hermeneutics, Bibliology, Series - Disingenuousness
  • Disingenuousness and the Problem of the Obvious
  • Are Dispensationalists Fighting a Losing Battle?
  • “That’s just your interpretation”
  • Axioms for Bible Interpretation
  • "His premise is that the earth’s history is 7000 years."

Pagination

  • Page 1
  • Next page

More by Paul Henebury

  • False Logic: The Folly of Claiming the NT Is Needed to Rightly Interpret the OT (Part 2)
  • False Logic: The Folly of Claiming the NT Is Needed to Rightly Interpret the OT (Part 1)
  • Puritan Books Evaluated: Part 11 – The Works of John Boys
  • The “Purpose – Outcome” Model: Teleology & Eschatology
  • Puritan Books Evaluated: Part 10 – The Works of Hugh Binning

Pagination

  • Page 1
  • Next page

Featured Resources

Cover Image

View at Amazon


(About Amazon links)

To make an apt answer is a joy to a man, and a word in season, how good it is!

(ESV, Proverbs 15:23)

Footer

  • About
  • Contact
  • Search
  • Forum

Since 2005

Image
2005 SI Logo Image