Is "what the Bible says" still the top criteria in Conservative Evangelical/Fundamental Christianity in the West?
I am going to say this twice, once at the beginning and once at the end, because the nature of this question is begging to be misunderstood.
Here goes: The issues are not the value of academic study or the value of scholarship. The issue is final authority and, secondarily, the priesthood of all believers.
I have seen arguments trying to persuade Christians to join their camp because they have the big name scholars. What has been lost, IMO, is the argument to embrace a certain position/doctrine on the basis of clear Scriptural argument.
Discussion