The Importance of Imagination, Part 1

9 replies [Last post]
Kevin T. Bauder
Offline
User
Joined: Sat, Jun 6 2009
Posts: 196

NickOfTime

Enter the Imagination

Picture yourself exiting a train that you boarded miles ago by mistake. You’re not sure where the train was going, so you don’t know what station you are in now. You only know that you are in a large city. The sign in the depot informs you that no other train will leave for days. You decide to rent a car so that you can find food and lodging. As you pull out of the parking garage, however, you discover that you are driving through a blizzard. The air is so full of snow that you can barely see the pavement in front of you. Occasionally a swirl will allow you to glimpse tall buildings or other features of the city. When you get close enough, you can sometimes spot a street sign, but the names are meaningless to you. In the meanwhile, the snow is piling up on the windshield and the glass is fogging over. Before you have driven half-a-mile, you are completely lost. You have no idea how to find your way.

This picture is a metaphor for the human condition. Our world is like the city. It is not merely a random collection of particulars, but an ordered system. If we could perceive the order, we would be in a position to get where we needed to go—assuming that we knew where that was. Our problem is that our senses are so bombarded with events and objects (i.e., with facts) that we are simply overwhelmed by the blizzard. This problem exists at three levels. First, the sheer number of facts is immense. Even a small room comprises more events and objects than we could take cognizance of in a lifetime. Second, our sensory apparatus (by which I mean not only the senses themselves, but our ability to register and relate facts) is limited and easily overwhelmed. It regularly shuts out most of what our senses do actually detect. Third, our ability to register and relate facts is directed, not by a neutral intellect, but by a will that determines in advance to arrange at least some facts in certain ways. In brief, we are caught in a blizzard with snow piling up on the windshield and the glass fogging over.

Somehow, what we need to do is to build up in our minds a map of immanent reality (“the city”) that will allow us to navigate its contours and, eventually, to leave it safely. This map will provide us with an internal image of the city. Such an internal image, if accurate, is capable of directing us even when our vision of the facts is largely obscured.

Everyone without exception attempts to construct such an inner image of the world. We begin the process of mapping this image before we are even aware that we are doing it. Tradition and education impose upon our minds large pieces of the total image. Investigation and reason allow us to fill in certain gaps. We all use an inner image or mental map to navigate through an immanent reality that we can only dimly discern.

Over time, this inner image may become so habitual that it feels natural to us. We begin to mistake our map of reality for reality itself. Occasionally, however, we encounter circumstances that remind us that we are navigating by a map. We sometimes come abruptly upon a dead end for which we are not prepared. We may take a turn, only to discover that we aren’t going where we thought we were. At such moments, we bump into reality itself.

Or we may find ourselves surrounded by people who navigate by an entirely different inner map. At those times, we experience what is called “culture shock.” The shock lies, first, in recognizing that their image of the world seems as natural to them as ours does to us and, second, in realizing that our map often sends us careening into these others, resulting in damage that can be quite real. If we are surrounded by a sufficient number of these people for a long enough time, we will be forced to learn significant portions of their map. Otherwise, we cannot survive.

We are all guided by an image of the world. Our image may be more or less in agreement with the images used by others. It may be more or less in agreement with reality itself. Nevertheless, such an inner map or image of the world is indispensible for human existence.

To say that we are all guided by some inner image of the world is to say that we imagine the world. Imagination is, in the broadest sense, the capacity to form images. Since each of us puts together an image of the world, each of us imagines the world. Certainly we do not all imagine the world the same way. One person imagines it to be thus and another person so. The point is, however, that without some inner image by which to navigate—without imagining the world—we would simply be paralyzed. None of us would go anywhere and none of us would accomplish anything, either for good or for evil.

We imagine the world. This observation is truly fundamental to a right understanding of human existence and of the human condition. The question is, Where does this inner map come from? How do we construct an image of the world?

The Holy Scriptures I

George Herbert (1593-1633)

Oh Book! infinite sweetness! let my heart
Suck ev’ry letter, and a honey gain,
Precious for any grief in any part;
To clear the breast, to mollify all pain.

Thou art all health, health thriving, till it make
A full eternity: thou art a mass
Of strange delights, where we may wish and take.
Ladies, look here; this is the thankful glass,

That mends the looker’s eyes: this is the well
That washes what it shows. Who can endear
Thy praise too much? thou art heav’n’s Lidger here,
Working against the states of death and hell.

Thou art joy’s handsel: heav’n lies flat in thee,
Subject to ev’ry mounter’s bended knee.


This essay is by Dr. Kevin T. Bauder, president of Central Baptist Theological Seminary (Plymouth, MN). Not every professor, student, or alumnus of Central Seminary necessarily agrees with every opinion that it expresses.

Aaron Blumer
Aaron Blumer's picture
Offline
UserEditorAdmin
Joined: Mon, Jun 1 2009
Posts: 5090
Speculative fiction

This piece reminds me of what I love about speculative fiction when it's at its best. Sci-fi and fantasy fiction give a writer the opportunity to 1- imagine a different world and 2-create different maps for perceiving the world via the characters. Some of the best stories are ones in which a human being of our own world (more or less) and having a "map" much like ours experiences all the map rearranging of encoutering an alien being or alien culture.
Yeah, it's not for everybody, I guess, but it's kind of fun to have your paradigms twisted temporarily once in a while. And affords some opportunities to examine your "map."

As for the whole map idea, I agree w/KB that this is how we perceive the world. Where I differ (probably... has looked that way in the past) is on a) how much the map differs de facto from reality, b) how much the maps of people of one culture or one era must necessarily differ from the maps of people of another (say, ancient times, for example) and c) how often the map differences really matter much.

But that they do differ, and sometimes in huge ways, I don't doubt in the least.

Edit: for example, KB refers to a reality "we can only dimly discern." I'm not yet convinced that the margin between perception and reality is always (or even usually) that immense.

Anne Sokol
Anne Sokol's picture
Offline
User
Joined: Tue, Jun 2 2009
Posts: 504
my phd

i once thought about pursuing a phd so i could study the imagination. It's a highly overlooked spiritual faculty. i think the imagination is distinctly connected to why/how we are able to have faith in things we cannot see.

KB takes one angle on this topic in this peice that seems a little mysterious. from what i'm reading of dallas willard right now (the divine conspiracy), willard would probably say we need to use imagination to see the world and reality the way Jesus said it is, to help us actually believe (and hence live) what it is we know factually.

anyway, very interesting and unexplored topic.

p.s. for those scared of the dark, instead of imagining monsters, imagine angels ("the angel of the Lord encamps around those who fear him.") It's quite life-changing . . . that's the voice of experience speaking Wink

CLeavell
CLeavell's picture
Offline
User
Joined: Wed, Jun 10 2009
Posts: 25
Thanks

Great introduction to a very important subject. I am very excited about this series of essays.

I recently read a great quote by C.S. Lewis on the relationship between imagination and truth…

Quote:

For me, reason is the natural organ of truth; but imagination is the organ of meaning. Imagination, producing new metaphors or revivifying old, is not the cause of truth, but its condition.

RPittman
RPittman's picture
Offline
Former member
Joined: Tue, Sep 15 2009
Posts: 1170
Value of speculative thinking.............
Aaron Blumer wrote:

This piece reminds me of what I love about speculative fiction when it's at its best. Sci-fi and fantasy fiction give a writer the opportunity to 1- imagine a different world and 2-create different maps for perceiving the world via the characters. Some of the best stories are ones in which a human being of our own world (more or less) and having a "map" much like ours experiences all the map rearranging of encoutering an alien being or alien culture.
Yeah, it's not for everybody, I guess, but it's kind of fun to have your paradigms twisted temporarily once in a while. And affords some opportunities to examine your "map."

Perhaps the value here is not that these fictions and fantasies point us in the direction of truth or even reality but they show us alternative ways of seeing.

Quote:

As for the whole map idea, I agree w/KB that this is how we perceive the world.

Purely from the map idea, it is going to be an impossibility to establish true north. However, this is where the enigmatic role of the Holy Spirit appears. I have yet to see a satisfactory explanation, or even discussion of His guiding influence within the believer. We profess it and we claim it but we cannot explain it or satisfactorily factor it into our overall view of reality.

Quote:

Where I differ (probably... has looked that way in the past) is on a) how much the map differs de facto from reality,

Well, we probably need to more closely define reality. If you're speaking of the common day-to-day reality of living in the physical world, then we have some correspondence. Otherwise, if you're speaking of ultimate/final reality, then we are light years away.

Quote:

b) how much the maps of people of one culture or one era must necessarily differ from the maps of people of another (say, ancient times, for example)

Yes, there's a major difference. I can map the change within my lifetime. This brings into question the scholarship on ancient cultures. How can we know without experiencing what cannot be conveyed with words? It casts a jaundiced eye on the pedantic scholarship turning upon tiny differences and subtle nuances of words. How can we test the veracity of scholarship?

Quote:

and c) how often the map differences really matter much.

But they do matter--they matter immensely. This has been my hammer in our discussions of other threads. There are plausible alternative views outside of the commonly accepted pablum.

Quote:

But that they do differ, and sometimes in huge ways, I don't doubt in the least.

It is not only important to recognize that differences do exist and what they are but it is also very important to realize the ramifications.

Quote:

Edit: for example, KB refers to a reality "we can only dimly discern." I'm not yet convinced that the margin between perception and reality is always (or even usually) that immense.

We only dimly discern physical reality much less metaphysical reality. Even our best scientific understanding is a ever-changing model of the thing itself.

Aaron Blumer
Aaron Blumer's picture
Offline
UserEditorAdmin
Joined: Mon, Jun 1 2009
Posts: 5090
Part 2

Part 2 is very helpful for understanding where he's going with analogy.
For my part, I continue to believe that most "normal" people perceive physical (aka "immanent") reality pretty accurately most of the time. If they didn't, they'd walk off a cliff or actually eat that very green piece of pizza they discover buried in the fridge. Laughing out loud

RPittman
RPittman's picture
Offline
Former member
Joined: Tue, Sep 15 2009
Posts: 1170
Imagination and visualization......
Anne Sokol wrote:

i once thought about pursuing a phd so i could study the imagination. It's a highly overlooked spiritual faculty. i think the imagination is distinctly connected to why/how we are able to have faith in things we cannot see.

KB takes one angle on this topic in this peice that seems a little mysterious. from what i'm reading of dallas willard right now (the divine conspiracy), willard would probably say we need to use imagination to see the world and reality the way Jesus said it is, to help us actually believe (and hence live) what it is we know factually.

anyway, very interesting and unexplored topic.

p.s. for those scared of the dark, instead of imagining monsters, imagine angels ("the angel of the Lord encamps around those who fear him.") It's quite life-changing . . . that's the voice of experience speaking Wink

This sounds something like the visualization advocated by Agnes Sanford, which is similar to old shamanic practices. Does Willard mention Sanford along with this? The mysticism scares me a little. I've heard this same argument for the denial of all sorts of things--illnesses, financial disaster, personal problems, etc. How does our use of imagination, both as an idea and practice, compare with the Biblical? cf. Genesis 6:5, 8:21, etc.

RPittman
RPittman's picture
Offline
Former member
Joined: Tue, Sep 15 2009
Posts: 1170
Clyde Kilby
CLeavell wrote:

Great introduction to a very important subject. I am very excited about this series of essays.

I recently read a great quote by C.S. Lewis on the relationship between imagination and truth…

Quote:

For me, reason is the natural organ of truth; but imagination is the organ of meaning. Imagination, producing new metaphors or revivifying old, is not the cause of truth, but its condition.

The late Clyde Kilby, a C.S. Lewis scholar at Wheaton, wrote extensively on C. S. Lewis, imagination, and faith. His work is well worth reading. Imagination and the Spirit, a festschrift honoring Kilby, is a good read too.

RPittman
RPittman's picture
Offline
Former member
Joined: Tue, Sep 15 2009
Posts: 1170
Perception and learned behavior.............
Aaron Blumer wrote:

Part 2 is very helpful for understanding where he's going with analogy.
For my part, I continue to believe that most "normal" people perceive physical (aka "immanent") reality pretty accurately most of the time. If they didn't, they'd walk off a cliff or actually eat that very green piece of pizza they discover buried in the fridge. Laughing out loud

Aaron, there's fodder here for a psychological debate here as to how much is perception and how much is learned behavior. Some interesting experiments (Gibson, E. J., & Walk, R. D. (1960). The "visual cliff." Scientific American, 202, 67–71 and Fantz, R. L. (1961). The origin of form perception. Scientific American, 204(5), 66–72) have been done with infants regarding their perception when placed on a table with plate glass extending the surface area over apparent space (i.e. the visual cliff experiment). However, I am not disagreeing although most folks stumble through life with their share of scrapes, bumps, and bruises.

Susan R
Susan R's picture
Offline
ModeratorUserUser accounts adminAdmin
Joined: Wed, May 6 2009
Posts: 3214
You're gonna' love this site, Aaron
Aaron Blumer wrote:

This piece reminds me of what I love about speculative fiction when it's at its best. Sci-fi and fantasy fiction give a writer the opportunity to 1- imagine a different world and 2-create different maps for perceiving the world via the characters. Some of the best stories are ones in which a human being of our own world (more or less) and having a "map" much like ours experiences all the map rearranging of encoutering an alien being or alien culture.
Yeah, it's not for everybody, I guess, but it's kind of fun to have your paradigms twisted temporarily once in a while. And affords some opportunities to examine your "map."

What is really cool is how many advances in technology were conceived by science fiction authors.

The imagination tethered by reality is a very useful tool.

__________________

Susan R

Blogging at Sunniemom's Survival Guide